This paper tackles deep clustering evaluation challenges in high-dimensional data.
problem Evaluation of deep clustering methods is problematic due to the curse of dimensionality and variations in embedding spaces.
method Develops a theoretical framework to highlight the ineffectiveness of internal validation measures and proposes a systematic approach to applying clustering validity indices in deep learning.
result The proposed framework reduces misguidance from improper use of clustering validity indices in deep learning.
Develops a new cluster validity index to find multiple optimal cluster numbers.
problem Finding the optimal number of clusters in real-world data with varying densities, sizes, and shapes.
method A new correlation-based cluster validity index that yields multiple local peaks.
result The new index finds multiple optimal cluster numbers in various scenarios.
reval package selects best clustering solutions via stability-based validation.
problem Challenges in determining best clustering solutions due to lack of validation methods.
method Stability-based relative clustering validation methods.
result Determines best clustering solutions that generalize to unseen data.
The paper challenges the validity of cluster validity measures in unsupervised learning.
problem The validity of cluster validity measures in selecting optimal clusterings.
method The authors investigate the use of cluster validity measures as objective functions in unsupervised learning and introduce a new variant of the Dunn index.
result Many cluster validity measures promote clusterings that do not match expert knowledge well.
CAF-HFCM automatically forms a cluster hierarchy and optimizes the number of clusters without trial-and-validation.
problem Challenges in determining the optimal number of clusters in fuzzy c-means.
method CAF-HFCM, an auto-fused hierarchical fuzzy c-means method.
result Automatic agglomeration and optimal number of clusters without validity indices.
Paper introduces NICc for fast cluster-based validation of prediction models.
problem Validation of prediction models on clustered data.
method Derived NICc to approximate leave-one-cluster-out deviance for standard regression models.
result NICc provides more accurate model size and variable selection, especially with strong clustering.
CARVE validates clustering results using resampling and stability analysis.
problem Inconsistent and unreliable clustering results due to algorithm, preprocessing, and k sensitivity. method CARVE uses resampling-based validation and stability analysis to evaluate multiple clustering algorithms and hyperparameters.
result CARVE consistently recovers near-optimal clusterings and finer biological structure.
New validity index for fuzzy-possibilistic c-means clustering.
problem Conflicting results in determining the optimal number of clusters due to noisy data points and outliers.
method Introducing a new validity index (FP index) for fuzzy-possibilistic c-means clustering.
result FP index works well in datasets with varying cluster shapes and densities.
Enhances clustering quality evaluation in noisy data.
problem Reliable clustering quality assessment in noisy Gaussian mixtures.
method Feature Importance Rescaling (FIR) method.
result FIR improves correlation between cluster validity indices and ground truth.
Cluster analysis is used to explore structure in unlabeled data sets in a wide range of applications. An important part of cluster analysis is validating the quality of computationally obtained clusters. A large number of different internal indices have been developed for validation in the offline setting. However, thi…
New criterion assesses cluster separability for validation.
problem Validating cluster analysis results and determining the number of clusters.
method Distinguishability criterion, combined loss function-based framework.
result Validated cluster configurations and determined the number of clusters.
Study benchmarks 26 clustering validity measures.
problem Determining the best clustering solution from candidates.
method Enhanced revision of previous methodology with three sub-methodologies.
result Comprehensive evaluation of 26 internal validity indexes.
Introduces BCVI, a Bayesian cluster validity index for better cluster selection.
problem Selecting the optimal number of clusters in clustering algorithms.
method Develops BCVI using Dirichlet or generalized Dirichlet priors, evaluated against existing indices.
result BCVI offers clear advantages in scenarios where user expertise is valuable.
This paper reviews and proposes a new approach for evaluating internal cluster validation indices.
problem Selecting the best-performing unsupervised classification algorithm without external information.
method Examines and proposes a new evaluation approach for internal validation indices.
result Suggests a new evaluation approach for internal validation indices.
HD-BWDM improves clustering validation in high-dimensional data.
problem Determining the right number of clusters in high-dimensional data.
method HD-BWDM integrates random projection, PCA, trimmed clustering, and medoid-based distances.
result HD-BWDM remains stable and interpretable under high-dimensional projections and contamination.
CDL index improves clustering validation for non-convex data.
problem Selecting clustering algorithms and hyperparameters without labeled data.
method CDL uses compactness, centers, and covariances to compute a probabilistic description length bound.
result CDL outperforms conventional CVIs on synthetic and image benchmarks.
New method for selecting clusters in residential electricity data.
problem Selecting useful clusters in electricity consumption data.
method Formalizing expert knowledge as external validation measures.
result Successfully reconstructed customer archetypes.
A new measure normalizes clustering accuracy to evaluate algorithms better.
problem Evaluation of clustering algorithms is challenging due to limitations of existing measures.
method Proposes a new, normalised clustering accuracy measure.
result The new measure identifies worst-case scenarios and is more interpretable.
This paper evaluates and validates cluster results using external and internal evaluation methods.
problem Evaluating and validating the quality of clustering results.
method External evaluation using Homogeneity, Correctness, and V-measure scores; internal evaluation using Silhouette Index and Sum of Square Errors.
result Validation of the number of clusters using dendrogram and statistical frequency distribution.
Method selects valid IVs from a large set using clustering and test of overidentifying restrictions.
problem Selecting valid instrumental variables from a large set of candidates.
method Agglomerative hierarchical clustering combined with a test of overidentifying restrictions.
result Achieves oracle properties when the largest group of IVs is valid.
New indices for determining cluster compactness and separability.
problem Challenges in identifying true clusters in data sets.
method Developed absolute cluster indices to measure compactness and separability.
result Demonstrated improved performance compared to existing indices.
iCVI-ARTMAP accelerates clustering with adaptive resonance theory and validity indices.
problem Improving clustering efficiency and accuracy using adaptive resonance theory.
method Integrates adaptive resonance theory (ARTMAP) with incremental cluster validity indices (iCVIs) for clustering.
result Significantly reduces clustering time and outperforms other methods on synthetic and real-world data.
Clustering is an extensive research area in data science. The aim of clustering is to discover groups and to identify interesting patterns in datasets. Crisp (hard) clustering considers that each data point belongs to one and only one cluster. However, it is inadequate as some data points may belong to several clusters…
New cluster validity index detects optimal number of clusters and secondary options.
problem Determining the optimal number of clusters in fuzzy clustering.
method Correlation-based fuzzy cluster validity index (WP index) using fuzzy c-means algorithm.
result WP index outperforms existing indexes in detecting optimal number of clusters and secondary options.
CSTS benchmarks time series clustering by evaluating correlation structures.
problem Lack of validated ground truth for objectively assessing clustering quality.
method Synthetic benchmark CSTS for evaluating correlation structures in multivariate time series data.
result CSTS enables precise diagnosis of methodological limitations in correlation-based time series clustering.
A new CVI called DSI evaluates clustering results without true labels.
problem No universal CVI for clustering without true labels.
method DSI based on data separability measure.
result DSI is an effective, unique, and competitive CVI.
New criterion selects optimal number of clusters based on stability.
problem Challenges in selecting optimal number of clusters in non-parametric clustering.
method Proposes a stability-based validation criterion combining between-cluster and within-cluster stability.
result Empirically demonstrates effectiveness in selecting optimal number of clusters.
A method for clustering small datasets in high dimensions using random projections.
problem Challenges in clustering small datasets in high-dimensional spaces.
method Random projection followed by binary clustering in one-dimensional space.
result Statistically significant clustering structures can be found with as few as 100-200 points.
Study proposes a statistical testing framework for evaluating clustering pipelines.
problem Quantifying the statistical reliability of clustering results from data analysis pipelines.
method Selective inference-based statistical testing framework for clustering pipelines.
result The proposed test controls the type I error rate and is effective in validating clustering results.
A new measure identifies clusters without assuming data distribution.
problem Identifying the correct number of clusters in data without distribution assumptions.
method Nonparametric interpoint distance-based approach.
result Superior to existing clustering measures, validated on synthetic and real data.
Study finds RVIs unreliable for SP selection in clustering.
problem Reliability of RVIs for selecting Similarity Paradigms (SPs) in clustering.
method Extensive experiments with 7 RVIs on synthetic and real-world datasets.
result RVIs are unreliable for SP selection.
Paper addresses limitations of traditional hierarchical clustering methods.
problem Traditional hierarchical clustering methods face limitations in binary trees and ultrametrics.
method Introduces the notion of a valid hierarchy and a two-step algorithm to construct a binary tree and prune it to enforce validity.
result Proposes a method to recover the finest valid hierarchy, which is not constrained to binary structures.
Probabilistic fair clustering tackles uncertain group membership.
problem Fair clustering with imperfect group membership.
method Probabilistic algorithms for metric graphs and metric membership.
result Approximation ratio guarantees for fair clustering.
One challenge impeding the analysis of terabyte scale x-ray scattering data from the Linac Coherent Light Source LCLS, is determining the number of clusters required for the execution of traditional clustering algorithms. Here we demonstrate that previous work using bi-cross validation (BCV) to determine the number of …
FunCLBM clusters time series data for autonomous driving validation.
problem Validation of autonomous driving systems using large amounts of data.
method FunCLBM model for co-clustering high-dimensional time series data.
result FunCLBM provides structured partition and clustering views of datasets.
One basic requirement of many studies is the necessity of classifying data. Clustering is a proposed method for summarizing networks. Clustering methods can be divided into two categories named model-based approaches and algorithmic approaches. Since the most of clustering methods depend on their input parameters, it i…
We use statistically validated networks, a recently introduced method to validate links in a bipartite system, to identify clusters of investors trading in a financial market. Specifically, we investigate a special database allowing to track the trading activity of individual investors of the stock Nokia. We find that …
Proposes DISCO, the first CVI for density-based clustering with noise.
problem Evaluation of noise assignments in density-based clustering.
method Density-connectivity and Silhouette Coefficient adaptation for noise evaluation.
result DISCO is the first CVI to explicitly assess noise assignments.
In addition to finding meaningful clusters, centroid-based clustering algorithms such as K-means or mean-shift should ideally find centroids that are valid patterns in the input space, representative of data in their cluster. This is challenging with data having a nonconvex or manifold structure, as with images or text…
This paper presents a novel time series clustering method, the self-organising eigenspace map (SOEM), based on a generalisation of the well-known self-organising feature map (SOFM). The SOEM operates on the eigenspaces of the embedded covariance structures of time series which are related directly to modes in those tim…
Machine learning systems increasingly depend on pipelines of multiple algorithms to provide high quality and well structured predictions. This paper argues interaction effects between clustering and prediction (e.g. classification, regression) algorithms can cause subtle adverse behaviors during cross-validation that m…
Validation is one of the most important aspects of clustering, but most approaches have been batch methods. Recently, interest has grown in providing incremental alternatives. This paper extends the incremental cluster validity index (iCVI) family to include incremental versions of Calinski-Harabasz (iCH), I index and …
Randomized hierarchical clustering tests for stability and detects clusters.
problem Greedy hierarchical clustering's sensitivity to data perturbations.
method Randomization scheme and p-values at each node.
result Valid hypothesis testing procedures for clustering results.
The paper provides guarantees for clustering validity without distributional assumptions.
problem Validating clustering results without distributional assumptions.
method Generic method to obtain post-inference guarantees of near-optimality and stability for clustering.
result The guarantees do not depend on distributional assumptions but depend on the data set admitting a stable clustering.
The nowadays massive amounts of generated and communicated data present major challenges in their processing. While capable of successfully classifying nonlinearly separable objects in various settings, subspace clustering (SC) methods incur prohibitively high computational complexity when processing large-scale data. …
clusterBMA combines clustering results from multiple models using Bayesian model averaging.
problem Uncertainty in model selection for clustering.
method Bayesian model averaging to combine results from multiple clustering algorithms.
result ClusterBMA offers probabilistic cluster allocations and quantifies model-based uncertainty.
Objective: To evaluate unsupervised clustering methods for identifying individual-level behavioral-clinical phenotypes that relate personal biomarkers and behavioral traits in type 2 diabetes (T2DM) self-monitoring data. Materials and Methods: We used hierarchical clustering (HC) to identify groups of meals with simila…
New method clusters variables using robust nodewise regression.
problem Variable clustering in multi-factor models.
method Distributionally robust nodewise regression with convex relaxation and ADMM.
result Superior performance in numerical studies.